The 77s are not the official band of Emergent. They are Emergent's cool uncle that never succeeded to his potential because he was unwilling to sell out and has been forgotten about when he should have been seen at the harbinger of the entire thing. In fact, what I said of Bazan has been said of and by Mike Roe, leader of The 77s on many occasions, that his music is "too holy for the world, and too worldly for the church."
The 77s problem is one of timing. In an internet age with myspace, iLike, Pitchfork and Paste, they would flourish. But when they began, there was no forum to express spirituality in popular music unless you were Irish/ British or black. For a bunch of church kids from California making exciting music, there was only one place; the burgeoning Christian Music scene, one that swallowed up some of the best musicians of the era: Charlie Peacock, Jimmy Abegg, The Choir, Daniel Amos, Gene Eugene and the best of the bunch- The 77s.
None of these bands should have been used for proselitization or Evangelistic purposes. Like Bono without proper guidance, they were not propagandists, preachers, salesmen for Jesus or called to "help God across the street like a little old lady." They were talented musicians with vision, passion, chops, pop sensibilities and the talent to thrive in the alternative/ college music scene of the 80s and 90s. They were artists that just happened to love Jesus and would express that in their lyrics. Instead they were relegated to church basements, festivals and the occasional college radio hit, snuck in by a closeted Christian disc jockey (i.e. ME).
After two of the most exciting things ever produced on a "Christian" label and blowing the mind of weird Christian kids everywhere, The 77s were poised for greatness with an Island records signing and great reviews in Rolling Stone. Alas, it never happened. That self titled album is something I have discussed with the old guard in the Emerging church and each can express their appreciation for an album that expressed Christian spirituality in a manner so real they had never known it was possible. These guys expressed what was really going on inside most of us. We did not feel the Amy Grant songs. But, we felt The Lust, The Flesh, The Eyes and The Pride of Life. Fir that, we will always be grateful. The 77s did more for my spirituality than any preacher or youth leader before I turned 21.
The music stretched boundaries and could be hard to keep up with. Classified as an alternative rock band, there were shades of Pet Sounds-era Beach Boys, Zeppelin, traditional blues and soul, Cheap Trick (I consider The 77s power pop at its best) and the 80s college rock of R.E.M. Lyrically, they started out with traditional Christian themes, but much more interesting in their execution (first Christian band I can think of to deal with abortion, teen pregnancy, binge drinking or Edgar Rice Burroughs in a song). They moved to more confessional lyrics, dealing with the grays of human experience, doubt, anger and longing. Even their songs about Scriptural themes had more in line with theologians such as Hauerwas, Volf, Moltmann and Brueggemann (I believe they were there intuitively, not because they were reading those theologians in the late 80s and early 90s) than Max Lucado. Like truly great artists, The 77s were ahead of the cultural curve (which kept them out of popularity in Christian circles) and precursors to the emerging church conversations.
Bands that get to sing about spiritual matters and sell records at the same time should call up a guy like Mike Roe up and thank him for paving the way. The rich ones should make sure he has insurance. Without guys like him, bands like mewithoutyou and Underoath would not be on Alternative Press, record companies like Tooth and Nail would not exist, Sixpence and
Switchfoot would not top the pop charts, David Bazan would not get to decide if he wanted to be a "Christian" artist or a mainstream artist and Cold War Kids and Sufjan Steven would not have top billing at alternative rock festivals around the nation.
Which is a shame for The 77s, because I would put their output between 1983 and 1995 up against anyone else's during that era. Mike Roe has the pop sensibilities of Brian Wilson, the guitar God chops of Jimmy Page, the gifts for lyrics of John Lennon and a creative streak on par with Roger Waters. He was a chameleon with a voice that could sing any genre effectively. Too much talent and too little audience. He needed Paste magazine to exist 10 years earlier.
Mike Roe and The 77s cannot be the official band of Emergent because their heyday is pre-Emergent. They are like those theologians, pastors, missionaries and professors that pioneered new forms and expressions of historic Christian faith and spirituality underground, toiling away with little fanfare, but paving the way for the popularizes, the guys and women living on the edge and influencing everyone by making art as good as, if not better than U2, R.E.M. and The Cure, bands that should have been their equals.
I need to stop because talking about how good the 77s were, how under appreciated they were, how influential they are and how important they are to the emerging church conversation. It saddens me because they toiled in the shadows for years and have been forgotten.